Seasonal & holiday

Special runs, limited by the oven.

A few times a year we bake things that aren’t on the regular board — and only as many as we can make well. Reserve early; when they’re gone, they’re gone.

Thanksgiving 2026

Reserve for Thanksgiving 2026

Signature Sourdough

$12

Our classic white sourdough loaf. Open crumb, blistered crust, mild sour. The one to buy first and the one to keep buying.

6 of 30 left
Allergens: WheatFerment: 30 hours

Baguette

$6

Crunchy, crispy crust, open chewy crumb. Best when enjoyed the day it is baked. You’ll want to buy two.

16 of 30 left
Allergens: WheatFerment: 24 - 36 hours

Cinnamon Swirl Sandwich Bread

$14

Soft crust sourdough swirled with a mix of organic cinnamon and cane sugar. Available Tuesday and Thursday only.

9 of 12 left
Allergens: Wheat · DairyFerment: 30 hours

Garlic & Herb

$14

The new and improved “Garlic & Rosemary”

39 of 60 left
Allergens: WheatFerment: 30 hours

Jalapeño Cheddar

$14

Signature sourdough with shredded cheddar cheese and dried diced jalapeño peppers. Owner favorite!

25 of 30 left
Allergens: Wheat · DairyFerment: 30 hours

French Onion

$15

Like French Onion Soup but its sourdough!

54 of 60 left
Allergens: Wheat · DairyFerment: 30 hours

Bread Bowl

$6

Signature sourdough bread bowl, half of a loaf.

25 of 30 left
Allergens: WheatFerment: 30 hours

Pumpkin Loaf

$15

Pumpkin bread with homemade pumpkin puree, warm spices, organic cinnamon and brown sugar.

26 of 60 left
Allergens: WheatFerment: 30 hours

Cinnamon Rolls

$8

Croissant dough rolled with butter and organic brown sugar and cinnamon. Served with a side of icing (organic powdered sugar and milk) Not too sweet — the ferment does the rest. Available only on Friday and Saturday.

17 of 30 left
Allergens: Wheat · DairyFerment: 24-48 hours

Whipped Honey Butter

$5

Whipped in house with Madison’s Reserve local honey and sea salt. A perfect balance of sweet and salty.

Sold out
Allergens: DairyFerment: Made fresh

Whipped Salted Butter

$5

Whipped in house with natural sea salt.

14 of 30 left
Allergens: DairyFerment: Made fresh

Whipped Herb Butter

$5

Whipped in house with organic rosemary, thyme and sea salt.

18 of 30 left
Allergens: DairyFerment: Made Fresh

Herb Croutons

$6

Made using day-old bread. Cubed and tossed in Zionsville Olive Oil, sea salt, organic rosemary and thyme and baked.

45 of 60 left
Allergens: Wheat

Dinner Rolls

$12

A dozen soft sourdough rolls, brushed with butter. Reheating instructions included.

Sold out
Allergens: Wheat · Dairy · eggsFerment: 30 hours

Taking orders now

Thanksgiving 2026

Pickup on Tuesday 24th or Wednesday 25th during your pickup window. Order by Friday the 20th.

Ordering closes Saturday, Nov 21.

Reserve for Thanksgiving 2026